At this year’s VMAs, Tori Kelly blew minds with her powerful performance. Though she’s still on the come-up, expect the former “American Idol” contestant to become much more well known, and soon. She’s enlisted Jeremih on a duet of her soulful single “Should’ve Been Us,” which cements her reputation as a voice to watch out for. She and Jeremih trade hooks over a chunky, cowbell-filled beat, telling both sides of a love affair gone wrong.

The original song can be found on Kelly’s debut album Unbreakable Smile, which features Ed Sheeran and LL Cool J.