Bobby Newberry and Melody Thornton head back to high school in the video for their second collaboration, a cover of Who Is Fancy’s “Goodbye.” Choreographer Newberry trades in his dancing shoes, while former Pussycat Doll Thornton adds her sultry vocals to the passionate ballad.

The prom-inspired clip, directed by Noel Maitland, showcases the highs and lows of a teenage love affair that ends in heartbreak. While they appear to be having a good time, Newberry is struggling with his sexuality and secretly yearns for someone else.

Watch their complicated love story unfold.